Social Policy Essays – Welfare State Development

Modern public assistance province development is by and large considered to take to societal security or benefits payments, societal lodging proviso, wellness proviso, societal work and educational services.

Together these services are known as the ‘big five ‘ but these services tend to develop over clip and have differed in measure, handiness and quality. Provision and development can alter due to societal, economic and political factors ( Spicker, 1995, p. 3 ) . State proviso of public assistance has a long history, in Britain for case dating back to the Elizabethan Poor Laws and before. Welfare provinces started to develop when studies of poorness by people such as Charles Booth showed the insufficiency of public assistance commissariats that could non cover with poorness peculiarly with increasing urbanization and industrialization ( Thane, 1996, p. 7 ) . The world-wide depression from 1929 would take states to see farther public assistance developments. High unemployment ( 12 % of the working population in Britain at its worst ) showed that better public assistance proviso was needed ( Robbins, 1994, p. 208 ) . From such modest roots the populace sector in Britain for illustration represents around 40 % of the economic system ( Simpson, 2005, p. 4 ) . There are assorted cardinal theories that seek to explicate the procedures involved in public assistance province development that will be explained below. The theories have evolved or being devised to explicate the differences and similarities in public assistance province development in different states at the same clip or in a individual state over a period of clip. Theories agree that public assistance provinces were developed to function those that needed help the most or sometimes as cosmopolitan services to all ( O’Brien and Penna, 1998, p. 2 ) . After the chief theories have been discussed the one or 1s that are most applicable for measuring modern-day alterations will be outlined.

There are different ways of looking at the development of the public assistance province and make up one’s minding how far it should widen, demands for alterations can ensue from improved engineering, switching societal or economic factors and demographic tendencies such as lower birth rates and people populating longer. As authoritiess have discovered public assistance provinces mean ‘people are populating longer and healthier lives ‘ which means that there are more pensionaries but less working people to prolong the pensions and excess wellness and attention services they need ( Department for Work and Pensions, 2005 p. 4 ) . Four cardinal theories of public assistance province development are based around liberalism, Marxism, Neo-liberalism and station structural linguistics and have all at some point been reflected in or used in the development of public assistance provinces. Developments in public assistance provinces can besides be reactive or proactive depending on the ideological purposes and visions of authoritiess or their ability to do societal policy ( Spicker, 1995, p. 35 ) .

Liberalism tended to emphasize the function of the person in supplying for their ain demands ; the province should merely step in to assist those that were incapable of happening work. The capitalist market would finally supply better lives for everyone ; there was merely a minimal function for province intercession ( O’Brien and Penna, 1998, p. 21 ) . In Britain the progressives originally achieved their purposes for public assistance province development with the 1834 Poor Law Act that eventually replaced the long lasting but no longer effectual act of 1601. Following the new act the hapless were put in workhouses where they had to work in return for being housed and fed ( O’Brien and Penna, 1998, p. 21 ) . Liberalism stressed in its original signifier that all the province demands to make is give persons the freedom to do their ain picks, merely assisting the truly impoverished. For them authorities merely needs to continue Torahs and belongings rights. The concern of authorities of concern was to let concerns to run freely ( R. Bellamy ‘Liberalism ‘ from Eatwell and Wright, 2003, pp. 27-28 ) . However some progressives recognised the defects of individualistic economic sciences peculiarly during recessions and slacks. They besides noted the weaknesss of the Poor Law to undertake poorness even during periods of bettering prosperity. There emerged new and extremist liberalism that called for increased public assistance proviso and the outgrowth of limited public assistance provinces. The British Liberal authoritiess of 1906-1914 epitomized that attack by presenting province old age pensions and labour exchanges for the unemployed ( Comfort, 1993, p. 347 ) . In contrast Germany had already had a well-developed public assistance province proviso by 1900. Curiously Bismarck who wanted a healthy knowing population drew up this system ( M Donald Hancock et Al, 1998, p.295 ) .

ALSO READ  Approaches to social policy

Two new progressives in the signifier of William Beveridge and John Maynard Keynes where the several designers of the Atlee authorities ‘s comprehensive public assistance province and postwar interventionist economic policies or Keynesian ( Bellamy from Eatwell and Wright, 2003, p. 33 ) .

Beveridge had plentifulness of experience in public assistance policy holding being in charge of the labor exchanges and talking on economic sciences at Oxford University and the London School of Economics. Keynes had been an economic sciences advisor to the British authorities and inspired the New Deal programme in the USA ( Crystal, 1998, pp. 105 & A ; 523 ) .

Marxism was developed by Karl Marx in concurrence with Fredrich Engels and led to a 2nd keynote theory of developing the public assistance province. Of class Marx and Engels were non concerned with such issues as they wished to advance communism and work towards the working categories taking over economic and political power from the capitalist categories. A Marxist province would develop a public assistance province to advance advancement, communism and above all protect the workers and extinguish poorness. Marx believed that capitalist economy would be replaced by communism therefore replacing the inequalities and giving everybody adequate to run into their demands ( O’Brien and Penna, 1998, p. 44 ) . The Marxist motion was non unified about how it would develop the public assistance province or so gain power. Some Marxists such as the German Social Democrats preferred to utilize parliamentary democracy to accomplish power and develop a public assistance province. The seminal Erfurt Programme of 1891 called for public assistance commissariats such as eight- hr working yearss, free health care, free instruction, minimal rewards and equality for adult females. More extremist Marxists such as Lenin and Trotsky advocated armed revolutions and were able to prehend power himself. The Soviet Union itself developed a public assistance province with free medical and instruction services and pensions with unemployment officially non-existent ( J.F Femia ‘Marxism and Communism ‘ from Eatwell and Wright, 2003, pp. 110-12 ) . In Imperial Germany, Bismarck set up the public assistance province to sabotage the socialists therefore chastening these wild animal of the political wood ( Hobsbawm, 1987, p. 102 ) . The Marxist-leninist governments of the Soviet Union and its Central and Eastern European orbiters may hold developed welfare provinces but they failed to bring forth the economic prosperity of the West and the many failures of their planned economic systems contributed to the autumn of these governments. On the other manus their population were all more economically equal, they were hapless but had free public assistance proviso and no political rights.

The 3rd chief keynote theory for public assistance province development is Neo-Liberalism most closely associated with the authoritiess of Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan. In Britain and other parts of Western Europe the combination of Keynesian economic sciences and all encompassing public assistance proviso that had helped to accomplish postwar prosperity faltered in the late sixtiess and the 1970s. Neo-Liberals believed that the combination of Keynesian economic sciences and the public assistance province were lending to economic and political stagnancy and were no longer feasible. Margaret Thatcher ‘s authorities elected in 1979 proceeded to once ditch Keynesian economic sciences and intended to cut back on the public assistance province ( O’Brien and Penna, 1998, p. 78-79 ) . Following policies that became known as Thatcherism nationalised industries were privatised, subsidies to ailing private companies were stopped, and council houses were sold off. These policies increased unemployment but finally lowered rising prices. Margaret Thatcher besides limited trade brotherhood power and defeated the mineworkers during the acrimonious work stoppage of 1984-1985. She brushed aside resistance to her policies as people accept there is no alternate ( Comfort, 1993, p. 608 ) . The planned decrease in outgo on the public assistance province ne’er materialised as higher unemployment pushed up benefit payments and more civil retainers were needed to treat those claims. The Conservatives found that the National Health Service was politically sacred although they were able to present an internal market to help efficiency. Neo-liberalism is a return to the thoughts of authoritative liberalism and views the province in the same negative visible radiation. However it has non being able to level the public assistance province merely to reform it ( O’Brien and Penna ( 1998 ) p. 103 ) . In the USA Reagan ‘s policies produced similar degrees of unemployment and poorness whilst increasing military disbursement well. Jessie Jackson accused Reagan of disbursement 1000000s to crush our ploughshares into blades, while go forthing the deprived beggary for staff of life Carroll and Noble, 1988, p. 437 ) . Reagan found it easier to disown public assistance and reject the bequest of the New Deal than Thatcher found it to change by reversal the construct of proviso from the cradle to the grave ( Hobsbawm, 1994, p. 249 ) .

ALSO READ  Planning Theory And Practice Social Policy Essay

Post-structuralism emerged at a similar clip to Neo-liberalism from the sixtiess. Unlike Neo-liberalism it does non see liberalism in any pretense or Marxism as equal methods of understanding societal and economic policy or as foundations for public assistance province development. Alternatively of concentrating on the province and persons Poststructuralism aims to understand ‘the relationships between cognition of societal life and the diffusion of power through society ( O’Brien and Penna, 1998, p. 105 ) . Marxism started to endure a crisis from the 1970s with its economic failings greatly sabotaging its societal and political foundations and conveying about the prostration of communism in Central and Eastern Europe ( Agh, 1998, p. 6 ) .

Actual public assistance province development is more frequently a mixture of more than one of these attacks. Development is frequently based on matter-of-fact concerns every bit much as ideological 1s. Political concerns peculiarly in broad democracies can order public assistance province development. Welfare measures that are electorally popular will frequently be implemented in front of reforms that would do the system more effectual yet could be electorally detrimental. Recent demographic alterations and future tendencies surely make public assistance province development a critical issue for the present and the hereafter. While those aged over 65 presently represent 16 % of the UK ‘s population by 2041 that figure is estimated to lift to 25 % . The UK ‘s authorities Actuary ‘s Department besides estimates that the on the job age subdivision of the population will diminish from 65 % to 58 % which is all those aged 16 to 64 ( DWP, 2005, p.16 ) . . Aging populations are a serious job to how welfare provinces as already developed can be sustained. By 1994 over 65 ‘s made up 15 % of the German population, 14.5 % of the Gallic population and 17.7 % of the Swedish population ( M Donald Hancock et Al, 1998 p. 90 ) .

By and large those of the left of the political divide are more likely to prefer a greater development of the public assistance province than those on the right who either maintain the position quo or cut it back if they can ( Spicker, 1995, p. 77 ) . Based on the facts of aging populations with fewer people of working age paying revenue enhancements to fund public assistance and benefits expenditure the latest tendencies in public assistance province development tend to emphasize aiming outgo to the most destitute, supplying value for money and forestalling fraud. In Britain New Labour has attempted to reform lodging benefit and introduced public presentation criterions to better disposal by local governments. The authorities has had some success in countering fraud ( DWP, 2003, pp. 32-39 ) .

ALSO READ  A Study On HNC Social Care Social Policy Essay

New Labour introduced the New Deal to assist immature people, handicapped people and solitary parents ‘ back into work. Since 1997, two million more people of working age have gained employment cut downing benefits outgo by 5 billion a twelvemonth, with the intent of undertaking the flagellum of unemployment, inaction and poorness ( DWP, 2005, p. 4 ) .

For Western Europe the keynote theory that best described public assistance province development up to the sixtiess would hold been fluctuations of liberalism with elements of socialism, for case British new liberalism and the West German societal market economic system. From the 1970s neo-liberalism and Poststructuralism had a greater influence on the development of public assistance provinces reflected most closely in the neo-liberal dogmas of Thatcherism in Britain. Neo-liberalism did cut down the size of public sectors in the states that tried it but its deflationary effects led to higher unemployment and higher benefits expenditure. Neo-liberalism would be the best theory to depict the public assistance province developments in Central and Eastern Europe after the terminal of communism. Over all neo- liberalism is now likely the best keynote theory with the provision that old broad and socialist as opposed to Marxist bequests are still evident and politically untouchable. The reforms needed to amend, widen and go on public assistance province development would best be considered under a Post-structuralist model. Welfare states particularly in the West face the turning challenge of supplying for the excess demands of aging populations whilst the on the job age populations needed to pay for them dwindles. Possible solutions could include raising retirement ages, carrying more people to supply for their ain wellness attention and pensions, promoting people to hold more kids or promote in-migration from developing states.


Agh, A. ( 1998 ) , The Politicss of Central and Eastern Europe Sage, London

Carroll, P.N. and Baronial, D.W. ( 1988 ) The Free and the Unfree- A new history of the United States 2neodymiumedition, Penguin, New York

Comfort, N. Dictionary ( 1993 ) Brewer ‘s Politicss a Phase and Fable Cassell, London

Crystal, D. ( 1998 ) The Cambridge Biographical Encyclopedia, 2neodymiumedition, Cambridge University Press

Department for Work and Pensions ( 2003 ) – Departmental Report 2003 The Stationery Office, London

Department for Work and Pensions ( 2005 ) – Five Year Strategy -Opportunity and Security throughout life The Stationery Office, London

Donald Hancock, M ; Conradt, D.P ; Guy Peters, B ; Safran, W. and Zariski, R. ( 1998 ) Politics in Western Europe 2neodymiumedition, Macmillan, London

Eatwell, R and Wright, A. ( 2003 ) Contemporary Political Ideologies 2neodymiumedition, Continuum, London

Hobsbawm, E. ( 1987 ) The Age of Capital 1875-1914, Weidenfeld & A ; Nicholson, London

Hobsbawm, E. ( 1994 ) The Age of Extremes – The short Twentieth Century 1914-1991, Michael Joseph, London

O’Brien, M. and Penna, S ( 1998 ) Speculating Welfare Enlightenment and Modern Society ‘ Sage Publications, London

Robbins, K. ( 1994 ) The Eclipse of a Great Power – Modern Britain 1870 – 1992, 2neodymiumedition, Longman, London

Simpson, J. ( January 2005 ) Meet Barry- he ‘s here to assist – Public service manager magazine

Spicker, P. ( 1995 ) Social Policy Themes and Approaches, Prentice Hall Harvester Wheatsheaf, London

Thane, P. ( 1996 ) Foundations of the Welfare State 2neodymiumedition Longman, London