Should same-sex marriage be legalized in Hong Kong?

Should same-sex matrimony be legalized in Hong Kong?

Content

  1. Introduction p.3-4
    1. Title and Description
      1. Title
      2. Description

1.2 Background

1.3 Research Objective

1.4 Focus Question

2.Research methodological analysis p.5

2.1 Questionnaire

2.2 Interview

2.3 Restrictions

2.3.1 Restrictions on questionnaire

3.Findings p.6-11

3.1 Findingss

3.1.1 People’s understanding towards the issue

3.1.2 People’s stance

3.1.3 Impacts on citizens and the society

3.1.4 Other suggestions

3.2 Interview sum-up

3.2.1 Interview 1

3.2.2 Interview2

4. Analysis p.12-14

4.1 People’s understanding towards the issue

4.2 People’s stance

4.3 Impacts on citizens and the society

4.4 Other suggestions

4.5 Restrictions

4.Conclusion p.15

5.Reflection p. 16

6.Bibliography P.17

7.Appendix p.18-25

1. Introduction

1.1title and description

1.1.1Title

Should same-sex matrimony be legalized in Hong Kong?

1.1.2 Description

Same-sex matrimony is a ceremonial brotherhood of two people of the same sex [ 1 ] , a matrimony or a marrige-like relationship between two work forces or two adult females. Through this undertaking, I would wish to happen out whether same-sex matrimony should be legalized in Hong Kong. Besides, to happen out other possible things that we can make to assist the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong.

1.2 Background

In recent old ages, same-sex matrimony has been legalized in different parts of the universe. More and more people support and talk out for the LGBT twosomes. It is such a hot and argumentative subject that it drew my attending and my involvements in happening out whether same-sex matrimony should be legalized in Hong Kong. What impacts will same-sex matrimony bring to the society? Is the legalisation of same-sex matrimony executable in Hong Kong?

Different parts of the universe are transporting out different policies protecting the rights of the LGBT twosomes. Until now, 18 states, including Argentina, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Luxembourg, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, the United Kingdom, Uruguay, the United States and certain sub-national legal powers, including parts of Mexico allow same-sex twosomes to get married [ 2 ] .

While in Hong Kong, what has the authorities done protecting the rights of the LGBT twosomes? Harmonizing to the information collected, the Hong Kong authorities has merely set up a ‘discrimination ordinance’ so far for protecting the LGBT twosomes from being discriminated and treated below the belt, which is non plenty for protecting the LGBT twosomes, and this affect the individuality of the LGBT citizens and their quality of life. In add-on to different related issues that raised, such as a transsexual lady contending for matrimony in Hong Kong. I decided to utilize this subject as the rubric of my independent question survey.

1.3 Research aims

From the background information, we know that the Hong Kong authorities has merely set up a ‘discrimination ordinance’ so far for protecting the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong from being discriminate, which is really limited. Due to this, I wanted to happen out ways for assisting the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong.

The aims of the independent question survey are as follow:

-to happen out whether same-sex matrimony should be legalized in Hong Kong ;

-to happen out how the quality of life of Hong Kong would be citizens affected if same-sex matrimony is legalized ;

-to happen out how the legalisation of same-sex matrimony would alter towards the societal individuality of Hong Kong citizens ;

-to find out other possible ways to assist protect the rights and battle for equality for the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong.

1.4 Focus Questions

-What has the Hong Kong authorities done so far for assisting

or profiting LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong?

-What jobs or troubles are LGBT twosomes confronting in Hong

Kong?

-What are the positive or negative impacts on societal facets

on general populace?

-What are the positive or negative impacts on societal facets

on LGBT twosomes?

-Other than legalising same-sex matrimony, can we/the

authorities do any other things to assist the LGBT twosomes?

2. Research methodological analysis

2.1 Questionnaire

The questionnaire consists of 14 MCs, the mark interviewee aged between 0-65. A entire no. of 337 samples have been collected and most of them aged between 10-18.

In the questionnaire, it includes inquiries like ‘what negative or positive impacts will the legalisation of same-sex matrimony be brought to the society? ‘ , ‘do you think that same-sex matrimony should be legalized in Hong Kong? ’ , etc. Through the questionnaire, I can happen out the positions of Hong Kong citizens towards this issue, how much they understand and support the issue.

ALSO READ  Child Adoption In England And Finland Social Policy Essay

2.2 Interview

Two interviews with representatives from Blessed Minority Christian Fellowship ( BMCF ) and the Equal Opportunities Commission have been conducted. The representative of the BMFC mentioned that they do back up the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, this is because God creates everyone and all people should be treated every bit. Whereas the representative of the Equal Opportunities Commission mentioned that they besides support same-sex matrimony, they think that there should be suited Torahs protecting the rights of people with different sexual orientations.

2.3 Restrictions

2.3.1limitations on questionnaire

The sampling size is non big plenty, it can’t stand for the position of the general populace. Apart from this, the sampling size is non broad plenty, as most of the respondents are female respondents and most of them aged between 10-18. Due to the above restrictions, the truth and the representativeness of the survey is therefore affected.

3. Findingss

3.1 Questionnaire

3.1.1People’s understanding towards the issue

In fig3.1, it shows whether the respondents know that same-sex matrimony has been legalized in 17 states. The figure shows that 51 % of the respondents didn’t whereas 49 % of they did.

In fig3.2, it shows whether the respondents know that the authorities has merely set up a ‘discrimination ordinance’ for protecting the rights of LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong. The figure shows that 58 % of the respondents knew that whereas 42 % of they didn’t.

3.1.2People’s stance

From fig. 3.3, when respondents were asked whether they think that same-sex matrimony should be legalized in Hong Kong, 78 % of them respond that they think that it should whereas 22 % of them think that it shouldn’t.

From fig3.4, it shows that most of the answering thinks that same-sex matrimony should be legalized as everyone is equal, some people thinks that it’s because of human rights, some thinks that Hong kong should be more unfastened, and a few people think of other grounds, such as love has no boundaries.

From fig3.5, it shows that most of the answering thinks that same-sex matrimony should non be legalized as it will take to tonss of argument, some people thinks that it affects moral and traditional value, the fewest respondents thinks that it’s because of reiligous ground.

3.1.3 Impacts on citizens and the society

From fig3.6, it shows that most of the answering thinks that same-sex matrimony will let Hong Kong citizens to hold a stronger sense of belonging, some of them thinks that it can better the populating criterion of Hong Kong citizens, can assist advance Hong Kong’s Economic development and a few respondents thinks that it can increase the freedom of HongKongers.

From fig3.7, it shows that most of the answering thinks that same-sex matrimony will impact teenagers’ values towards matrimony, and a few of the respondents thinks that it will take down the quality of life of the Hong Kong citizens and that they will hold a lower sense of belonging. A few of them besides thinks that it will impact the population of the city..

3.1.4 Other Suggestions

From fig3.8, it shows that apart from legalising the same-sex matrimony, respondents thinks that the authorities should put up Torahs to protect the rights of the LGBT twosomes, set up non-profit organisation or cooperate with NGOs to assist the LGBT twosomes that are in demand.

3.2 Interview Summary

3.2.1 Interview 1

The first interview was carried out with the representative of the Equal Opportunities Commission.

In the interview, the interviewee mentioned that their organisation support that the authorities should make something like puting up the SODO in order to assist the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong. But they have no stance towards the legalisation of same-sex matrimony.

Despite the fact that they don’t have a stance towards the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, I can see that they tend to back up it as they mentioned that they don’t see any disadvantages that may be brought approximately by the legalisation of same-sex matrimony and they think that the legalisation make the society more equal.

3.2.2 Interview 2

The 2nd interview was carried out with the representative of the BMCF.

In the interview, the interviewee mentioned that their organisation back up the legalisation of same-sex matrimony. However, as there are still many voices and different sentiments, they think that the authorities can foremost put up Torahs like the SODO or advance the civil brotherhood, and take farther actions like legalising same-sex matrimony in the hereafter.

ALSO READ  Food Aid Effect Agricultural Production Social Policy Essay

4.Analysis of findings

4.1People’s understanding towards the issue

From the information collected, it is shows that merely around half of the respondents know what have the authorities done so far for protecting the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong and that same-sex matrimony has legalized in 17 states. This reflects that Hong Kong citizens by and large don’t have a really clear apprehension on the issue on same-sex matrimony and the state of affairs of LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong.

4.2People’s stance

Despite the fact that the information collected shows that a minority of citizens do non back up the legalisation of same-sex matrimony in Hong Kong, as they think that the legalisation can take to tonss of argument which is non executable. It is still shown that most of the respondents back up the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, as they think that everyone is equal and that they should bask the same rights.

Furthermore, from the interviews conducted, it is known that the BMCF and some other related organisations support the legalisation of same-sex matrimony. Apart from this, the Equal Opportunities Commission tend to back up the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, as they mentioned that the legalisation of same-sex matrimony cause no injury to the society and that everyone, no affair what their sexual orientation are, should be treated every bit under the jurisprudence.

Apart from the questionnaires and interviews, from a study conducted by the Chinese University of Hong Kong, it’s shown that people with higher instruction degree have higher credence towards homosexual. As the society develops, people in Hong Kong are more educated and the degree of credence towards homosexual will be higher, the degree of acceptancy towards the legalisation is therefore higher and it shows that the legalisation of same-sex matrimony if executable.

The above reflects that the legalisation of same-sex matrimony is executable, as most respondents back up it. Apart from this, Hong Kong citizens by and large have a high acceptancy towards the LGBT twosomes and that everyone in the society should be treated every bit.

4.3Impacts on citizens and the society

For the positive impacts, it’s shown from the questionnaire that most respondents think that after the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, Hong Kong citizens will hold a stronger sense of properties. This is because they by and large thinks that after the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, the LGBT twosomes can bask the rights that normal twosomes do and they can be treated more every bit comparing with the current state of affairs, which improve their quality of life. The societal will be more harmoniousness as struggles between LGBT twosomes, citizens and the authorities will diminish, and this addition the sense of belonging of Hong Kong Citizens.

For the negative impacts, it’s shown from the questionnaire that most respondents think that after same-sex matrimony is legalized, the values of adolescents towards matrimony will be affected. This is because, at present, matrimony is known as a relationship between a adult male and a adult female, but when same-sex matrimony is legalized, they may get down to believe that matrimony can be a relationship between two work forces or two adult females alternatively of one adult male and one adult female. This can hence impact the traditional value. From the interview conducted with the Equal Opportunities Commission, the interviewee mentioned that in the traditional value of Chinese civilization, a adult male should get married with a adult female and reproduce their following coevalss, nevertheless, after the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, two people of the same sex may acquire marry and they won’t be able to reproduce to their following coevalss which affects the traditional value.

From the interview, it’s besides reflected that people who support and those who don’t have a really different ideas towards the impacts that will be brought approximately by the legalisation of same-sex matrimony. It’s mentioned that people who support the issue thinks that the legalisation of same-sex matrimony can do the society more just and equal as the LGBT twosomes can bask rights that normal twosomes do. Whereas, those who do non back up the issue thinks that the legalisation will take to unfairness as they may hold to portion their benefits and rights will the LGBT twosomes after the legalisation.

ALSO READ  Planning Theory And Practice Social Policy Essay

4.4 Other Suggestions

From the findings, it’s shown that most respondents think that the authorities should put up Torahs to protect the rights of the LGBT twosomes.

In the interviews conducted, both the BMCF and the Equal Opportunities Commission mentioned that they hope that the authorities can put up Torahs, for illustration the sexual orientation favoritism regulation, in order to protect the rights of the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong.

Apart from this, they besides think that the authorities can follow other states to transport out civil brotherhood, supplying more freedom and rights for the LGBT twosomes.

4.5Limitations

Some of the secondary informations used is excessively old and is non updated, this may impact the truth of the analysis.

5.Conclusion

The subject of my independent question survey is whether same-sex matrimony should be legalized in Hong Kong. Through this survey, I would wish to happen out whether same-sex matrimony should be legalized in Hong Kong ; how the quality of life of Hong Kong would be citizens affected if same-sex matrimony is legalized ; how the legalisation of same-sex matrimony would alter towards the societal individuality of Hong Kong citizens and other possible ways to assist protect the rights and battle for equality for the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong. Besides, I would wish to happen out replies for my focal point inquiries.

From the survey, I can see that most of the respondents back up the same-sex matrimony should be legalized. Although most people are back uping the issue, there are still many different voices and statements towards it. Some people do back up that same-sex matrimony should be legalized, as they think that under the jurisprudence, everyone is equal and that the LGBT twosomes should be treated every bit and should hold the chances to bask the same rights as normal twosomes do. However, there are still some people who do non back up the legalisation of same-sex matrimony, as they think that it can impact moral value, traditional value and the value towards matrimony of the following coevalss.

As there are still many different voices and sentiments, it’s known that same-sex matrimony can non be legalize in short term. But for the clip being, I think that the authorities can still take actions supplying aid for the LGBT twosomes in Hong Kong, for illustration puting up Torahs like the sexual orientation favoritism regulation or advancing the civil brotherhood.

6.Reflection

Through this survey, apart from cognizing more about what same-sex matrimony is, what difficulties the LGBT twosomes are confronting in Hong Kong, I besides learnt how to believe from multiperspective. For illustration, when I am analysing the information collected, I will seek to walk in the places of different stakeholders and think from their point of position and attempt to explicate why they have such an sentiment.

Personally, I support the legalisation of same-sex matrimony and I do trust that it can be legalized every bit shortly as possible. But as I know that there are still many different voices and sentiments on the issue, same-sex matrimony can non be legalized in short term. So at the clip being, I hope that the authorities can pass on with and roll up thoughts from the general populace foremost and take farther actions like advancing the civil brotherhood or puting up Torahs for assisting the LGBT twosomes every bit shortly as possible so as to let the LGBT twosomes to hold a better life.

Last, if I am making similar sorts of surveies once more, I will seek to roll up a larger sample size with wider distribution, so that I can hold a more accurate and dependable consequence for my findings.

7.Bibliography

1.Same-sex Marriage Law & A ; Legal Definition, USLegal, 2014,

& lt ; hypertext transfer protocol: //definitions.uslegal.com/s/same-sex-marriage/ & gt ; ( 16 November 2014 )

2. Same-sex matrimony, Wikipedia, 2015,

& lt ; hypertext transfer protocol: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-sex_marriage & gt ; ( 2July 2015 )

3.香港中æ-‡å¤§å­¸ 聯合æ›Â¸Ã©â„¢Â¢Ã©â‚¬Å¡Ã¨Â­ËœÃ¦•â„¢Ã¨â€šÂ²Ã§Â§‘ GEU4011M – 專題討è«-

& lt ; hypertext transfer protocol: //ucgeu.lib.cuhk.edu.hk/GEU/images/2009/GEU200910120.pdf & gt ; ( 1July2015 )

4. My3q, online quesionnaire

& lt ; hypertext transfer protocol: //my3q.com/research/yuichingcheung/59291.phtml & gt ; ( 1July2015 )

1

[ 1 ] Same-sex Marriage Law & A ; Legal Definition, USLegal, 2014,

& lt ; hypertext transfer protocol: //definitions.uslegal.com/s/same-sex-marriage/ & gt ; ( 16 November 2014 )

[ 2 ] Same-sex matrimony, Wikipedia, 2015,

& lt ; hypertext transfer protocol: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-sex_marriage & gt ; ( 2July 2015 )